Morocco’s Great Illusion

For the past three months, I have been struggling with the notion that Joseph de Maistre’s famous “every country has the government it deserves,” found in his “Lettres et Opuscules Inédits vol. 1, letter 53,” is indeed an accurate delineation of Morocco. Could it be conceivable that we, Moroccans, are not aware of the judiciary’s pliancy? Do we lack proof of the politicians’ venality? Does it come as a shock to us that the nation’s polity is task organized like a mafia where the King and his confederates, Mounir Majidi et al, are intolerant of criticism and intemperate in their disregard for basic standards of freedom? Do we need Ahmed Benchemsi and other journalists and intellectuals to inform us that this cartel monopolizes the country’s economic resources, controls its financial institutions, directs its security and military assets against civilians they perceive as threats to their personal interests, and eviscerates the minute grassroots opposition that occasionally flows into the streets to demand a participatory government?

We know all that!

As we watch the unfolding of a democracy we surely know to be illusionary, we bemoan how we lack representative political institutions. Those sleepy clowns we elect to the parliament we know to be beholden to the whims of an oligarchy of über-Moroccans no better, in fact worse, than any foreign colonizer. People jeer at how fractured Abdelilah Benkirane’s government is, how crude his ministers, whose directives are snubbed by subordinate officials, are. Mr. Benkirane finds himself making the same mistake Abderrahman al-Youssoufi committed during his tenure as a Prime Minister in the transitional government of 1998 – 2002: ingratiating himself with the King at the expense of his credibility in the street by excessively running to the palace to beseech the King’s imprimatur to force the application of any comprehensive reform on his own rank and file. Everybody is aware our spurious political opposition is a slapstick act. No one in Morocco is shocked to know that the economy is weak, corruption widespread, the education system bankrupt, healthcare inefficient, elections fraudulent.

We know all that!

We allow ourselves to be entertained by the old guard’s obstructionist strategies to the overly conservative reforms of the Islamist government. Cafés have been abuzz with how Faycal Laraichi and Samira Sitail are the steadfast withstanders of Islamisation, the last bulwark against the sweeping advance of an intolerant, misogynist Islamic discourse into Morocco ‘secular and permissive mindset. Mosques are filled with chatter about how Islam is under attack and the PJD is the shield protecting country and faith from a denigrating Western culture set on undermining our identity, stymieing our progress, indoctrinating our minds.

But there is a more salient reason why Morocco is a sinkhole for democracy. We gripe about the government more openly now, but we act little. We are an ambivalent and empathic lot, bloated by greed and spectacular cynicism. Everybody’s looking for a way to fool the system and con the other. Nurses who surreptitiously eat the food brought by families of patients under their care are not exceptions, nor are pregnant women who are forced to deliver their babies at the gates of a regional hospital deserted by its on-duty doctors. Ambulance drivers ask patients for “gas money” while government clerks demand their “cup of coffee,” euphemisms for bribery, in exchange for their services. The teachers, the doctors, the nurses, the civil servants, the lawyers, the judges, the policemen, the military, the politicians, and anybody in a position that bestows upon him an iota of power is for sale. When the Tunisian and Libyan governments collapsed, the Direction générale de la surveillance du territoire (DGST), Morocco’s counterintelligence service, was advised that the security services of Zine El Abidine Ben Ali and Mummar Gaddafi had recruited Moroccan journalists, intellectuals, parliamentarians, and government officials, as sources tasked to collect and report on their own country; in exchange for their services, they received salaries and gifts.

Integrity and philanthropy are raindrops in the desert. We condemn the repression of journalists, artists, and bloggers, but we suppose they deserve it after all; we preach tolerance and yet chastise those Moroccans who opt for different religions and cultures. We at once lament child servitude and accept it as a cultural fait accompli; we growl about the suicide of a teenage woman forced to marry her rapist, but rationalize the marriage as protection to her honor; we complain about trash in our streets, but we too litter.

The people want change so long it is designed and implemented by the King. He is regarded by most as a beacon of light among sleaze. Any such change cannot subvert his moral authority to govern. Forget about democratic institutions governed by laws and procedures; Moroccans would rather rely on one man’s wisdom and sense of justice. The King of course relies for his governance on a perfidious ecosystem of which the Moroccan society as a whole is a part.  No wonder then the Moroccan society is hardly reactive and has such high tolerance for political and economic shenanigans – in pari delicto. Its members are riddled with self-destructive pathologies. What’s worse? We are in denial. We have yet to face up to reality. We live in a paracosm in which frenzied adulation to the King and his entourage are rooted in the deepest recesses of our psyche. So long we remain this way, there will be no change for a thousand years to come.

A. T. B. © 2012

About cabalamuse

venture down those ominous ways thread into that austere city
This entry was posted in Abdelilah Benkirane, Child Labor, Democracy, HUMAN RIGHTS, JUSTICE, Moroccan Initiative, MOROCCAN JUSTICE, MOROCCO, Mummar Qaddafi and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Morocco’s Great Illusion

  1. What has prompted this tirade?

    • cabalamuse says:

      Si Yacine,
      It’s not a tirade; it’s an observation. Moroccans want change, but are unwilling to proactively create change. They want their environment to change, but are unwilling to start with themselves. You are an entrepreneur and you very well understand that any change will have to start with the ideas we nurture in our minds. There are exceptions of course. Groups of young activists organize themselves into civic association to positively affect their communities. Others campaign in the streets in an attempt to increase awareness – and for many years, I was among those. For the majority of Moroccans, it’s “fhama.” The viability of a change of mindset through future generations is improbable. Our next generation is of waifs and strays. The sociological and political elements necessary to engender change are not there.

  2. anonyme says:

    I couldn’t agree more with your assessment of the Moroccan society. Inertia is what characterizes a society. And the Moroccan society is extremely hard to move one way or the other.
    Don’t forget the constant bombardment of the average Moroccan by the official media. The propaganda machine of the Makhzen is an extremely well oiled engine that forces Moroccans to think that all the good initiatives originate with the king. Very few have the intellectual capability to see through this propaganda campaign. This is the real tragedy of the Moroccan political system. Ask any Moroccan what s/he thinks about the king, and there’s a high probability that they have a positive image of the king. They don’t see him as the businessman he is, they only see what the media have sold them. It takes a lot to be able to see the game played in Morocco from the outside,

  3. I’d argue that reiterating the political economic realities of the pinnacle of Moroccan society is a necessary step towards shedding that denial and the adherence toward the monarchy that is so widely held by Moroccans. I don’t deny that I could probably be categorized as one of those “journalists and intellectuals” who point to the monopolized nature of wealth and power in Morocco, but how can that awareness among Moroccans be assessed and measured? From the daily conversations I have with average Moroccans, including family members, there is still much to be said and discussed re: the nepotism and corruption that plagues Morocco. We may agree that exists, but we (Moroccan society) hasn’t agreed on its causes. Without agreeing on the causes, what positive steps can we take towards effective policy change? And, like you mention, so long as the monarchy is viewed as untouchable in terms of criticism, I think we’re sort of stuck in a limbo.

  4. oulaya says:

    Yes a lot of “fhamat” and not much change. However how do you go about implementing this change? When more than half of the population suffers from fear, lack of education and understanding of the situation, Yes We all know that bribery is the law of the land, we all know that you do not speak about the king or anyone that stands around him. Simple truths that we only dare to joke about within the company of our trusted friends. Yet this cynicism and indifference stem from the way we are raised and the way we are punished when we question authority be it our school teachers, parents or the government, it is very hard to break out from such habits that has been ingrained in our psyche. As to why they love him because most of them are old enough to remember the old regime. Moroccans are people that has spent their post-independence days been choked by a giant hand. So when the son relaxes his grip a little bit they get thankful and grateful just for a few wisps of air to the point that they forget that the hand is still around their necks and could crush them any day.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s